Death of Haitian youth sparks new protests against MINUSTAH

Sixteen-year-old Gerald Jean Gilles suffocated to death at Formed Police Units base

[Translation of an article from Brasil de Fato of São Paulo for September 14. See original article here.]

by Thalles Gomes

“They are suffocating me,” was the cry heard on August 17 by employees of the Henri Cristophe Hotel, in Cap-Haïtien, capital of the Nord department of Haiti. The call for help came from the Formed Police Units base belonging to MINUSTAH, the United Nations Mission for the Stabilization of Haiti. On that same day, Nepalese United Nations soldiers reported that Haitian Gerald Jean Gilles had entered their military base and had hanged himself.

The report issued by the UN did not explain how the young Gerald had managed to get into the military base, tie a rope on the patio and hang himself without any soldiers noticing.

Their version is contested vehemently by Gerald’s family and friends. According to them, the young man had been doing odd jobs for the Nepalese soldiers for some time in exchange for money or food. And the suspicion that Gerald had stolen 200 dollars from one of the soldiers was the reason the Nepalese soldiers tortured and suffocated him to death.

In fact, the real reason for the death of Gerald Jean Gilles is still undetermined. That is because MINUSTAH only released the young man’s body for autopsy more than 72 hours after his death, which could have changed the results of the forensic investigation. Death by suicide, meanwhile, has been ruled out since none of the victim’s cervical vertebrae were damaged.

This is not the first time Nepalese UN troops have been accused of misdeeds and abuses of authority. Several days before Gerald’s death, the local press reported charges that a Nepalese soldier had detained and tortured a minor openly in a public square in Cap-Haïtien, to the extent of “forcing his hands into the youth’s mouth in an attempt to separate his lower jaw from his upper jaw, tearing the skin of his mouth.” In 2008, the rape of an adolescent Haitian girl by soldiers from the Nepalese unit had international repercusions. After an internal investigation the UN declared that it would punish and remove the guilty parties.

Abuse and controversial activity are not limited to the Nepalese. On the night of May 24, 2010, Brazilian soldiers invaded the campus of the State University of Haiti on the pretext that a rock had been thrown at a MINUSTAH vehicle. Using batons and tear gas, the Brazilian soldiers confiscated books, notebooks and laptops from several students and detained student Mathieu Frantz Junior. The MINUSTAH tear gas grenades reached earthquake victims in improvised camps near the university. The special representative for MINUSTAH, Edmond Mulet, called the soldiers’ actions “hostile” and apologized publicly in an official statement.

This repeated hostility has been sparking numerous protests and demonstrations against the UN occupying troops. The streets of Cap-Haïtien were taken over in the past weeks by marches and public actions, with the participation of urban and rural movements, who demanded punishment of the Nepalese soldiers for the murder of Gerald Jean Gilles. Meanwhile, students at the State University of Haiti took to the streets of Port-au-Prince last September 4 to demand that action be taken for the arbitrary violent acts of the Brazilian soldiers, who have so far not been punished.

Crisis of Legitimacy

In place since 2004, when the United States military invasion removed from power then President Jean Bertrand Aristide, MINUSTAH is curently going through one of its greatest crises of legitimacy on Haitian soil. The initial objective of the mission, the stabilization of the country, no longer has any plausible justification, since the current indices of violence are lower here than in more developed countries like Brazil or South Africa. In the case of Brazil, the country whose army coordinates MINUSTAH troops, it experiences in its own territory an average of 57 homicides per 10,000 inhabitants, and the country hosting the last World Cup has 250 homicides per 10,000 inhabitants, while in Haiti, the number is only 15 homicides for every 10,000.

In addition, eight months after the earthquake that devastated the country on Jaunary 12, 2010, UN troops have still not managed to offer an adequate response to the victims of the tremor. Rubble and improvised encampments still fill the streets of the capital, Port-au-Prince, but no effort on the part of the troops to remove the rubble and begin constructing buildings is seen. Nor can a lack of funds or human resources be blamed since following the earthquake there was an increaseof 3,500 MINUSTAH personnel, with an increase of 126 million dollars to the budget in salaries alone. Needless to say, a soldier assigned to military service in Haiti receives close to 3,000 dollars a month, the equivalent of four years work for a Haitian living on the minimum wage.

Faced with this scenario, diverse sectors of the Haitian population question the real usefulness of a UN occupying force remaining in the country. “If MINUSTAH had been fulfilling its mission of promoting stability in the country and encouraging development, then how could it not have known that there was this risk of an earthquake? It should have known that there was this risk and proposed a series of measures and solutions to deal with it.. MINUSTAH should at least have helped the people. But they couldn’t even do that, support the people and organize food distribution,” declared Gerald Mathurin, coordinator of Kòdinasyon Rejyonal Òganizasyon Sidès (KROS – Southeastern Regional Coordinating Organization) and a member of Via Campesina Haïti. “The question of the military always accompanies the intentions of international powers when they need to do something in the country. The military who came before and those who come now still have the same mission, they always have the same objective, which is to carry out the project of imperialism,” Mathurin concludes.

In the midst of these denunciations, social movements in Haiti and Latin America plan to hold public events throughtout the continent in defense of Haiti’s national sovereignty and freedom next October 15. On that same date the UN Security Council will meet in New York to decide whether or not to renew the MINUSTAH’s mandate for another year. It will be an ideal opportunity for the international community to evaluate whether its much vaunted solidarity with the Haitian people really needs soldiers, weapons and tanks to be effective.

m4s0n501

Tags: , , , , , , ,

18 Responses to “Death of Haitian youth sparks new protests against MINUSTAH”

  1. Ansel Says:

    Thanks so much for translating this important article, David. I’m planning on going to Cap Haitien in the next two weeks – just got contacts for the Gillles family lawyer a few days ago.

  2. Tweets that mention Death of Haitian youth sparks new protests against MINUSTAH | lo-de-alla.org -- Topsy.com Says:

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by thezenhaitian and Janie B. Tijerina, Ansel Herz. Ansel Herz said: Death of #Haiti youth sparks new protests against MINUSTAH http://bit.ly/bUbbnm (I'm hoping to get up to Kap soon to report on this…) [...]

  3. david Says:

    Ansel,

    One more very ugly event. But I’m glad you’re working on a story on it and am looking forward to reading it.

    Best wishes.

  4. Death of Haitian youth sparks new protests against MINUSTAH /  Two Nations News Says:

    [...] Read full article HERE [...]

  5. Sonje Haiti Says:

    je vous remercie pour cette blog et les nouvelles

  6. CITIZEN PROTESTS, GOVERNMENT REPRESSION MOUNT IN HAITI | Jean Senat Fleury - Blog Says:

    [...] [6] See, for example, the reports of Harvard Law Student Advocates for Human Rights http://www.reliefweb.int/rw/RWFiles2005.nsf/FilesByRWDocUNIDFileName/VBOL-6B5J5U-harvard-haiti-mar05.pdf/$File/harvard-haiti-mar05.pdf and Human Rights Watch http://www.hrw.org/en/node/79214. MINUSTAH has also engaged in recent acts of violence against camp residents who have been ordered evicted by either the state or private landowners. And on May 23, MINUSTAH forces fired tear gas and rubber bullets into a crowded camp in downtown Port-au-Prince, leaving at least six people hospitalized and others suffering respiratory conditions. (See http://www.otherworldsarepossible.org/another-haiti-possible/united-nations-attacks-refugee-camp-protests-mount.)    Other charges of MINUSTAH violence include an attack by the forces in Cité Soleil on April 15, 2005, killing several (Eyewitness testimony, AP television news story, April 15, 2010); an attack on July 6, 2005, resulting in an uncertain number of deaths (http://www.cod.edu/people/faculty/yearman/cite_soleil.htm); the killing of at least five, and possibly many more, people in Cité Soleil in December 22, 2006 (http://www.cod.edu/people/faculty/yearman/cite_soleil.htm); and the shooting death of a young man at the funeral of a prominent priest on July 14, 2009 (http://www.sfbayview.com/2009/secret-funeral-for-a-minustah-victim/).  In Feb. 2008, the UN Office of Internal Oversight Services released findings from its investigation into accusations against Sri Lankan MINUSTAH troops, in which it found that acts of sexual exploitation and abuse of children were “frequent” and occurred “at virtually every location where the contingent personnel were deployed.” (Human Rights Watch, “Haiti: Events of 2008,” http://www.hrw.org/en/node/79214)   [7] Thalles Gomes, “Death of Haitian Youth Sparks New Protests against MINUSTAH,” Brasil de Fato, Sept. 14, 2010, http://lo-de-alla.org/2010/09/death-of-youth-sparks-protests-against-minustah/ [...]

  7. Citizen Protests, Government Repression Mount in Haiti | Amauta Says:

    [...] [7] Thalles Gomes, “Death of Haitian Youth Sparks New Protests against MINUSTAH,” Brasil de Fato, Sept. 14, 2010, http://lo-de-alla.org/2010/09/death-of-youth-sparks-protests-against-min… [...]

  8. Institute for Justice and Democracy in Haiti » Blog Archive » Citizen Protests, Government Repression Mount in Haiti Says:

    [...] on August 17.  MINUSTAH per­son­nel claimed that the youth killed him­self, a fact dis­puted by fam­ily and [...]

  9. Protests, Government-UN Repression Mount in Haiti « Frontlines of Revolutionary Struggle Says:

    [...] in Cap-Haïtien on August 17.  MINUSTAH personnel claimed that the youth killed himself, a fact disputed by family and [...]

  10. In UN Response to Peaceful Protest “I Feared for All Our Lives” // Mediahacker Says:

    [...] should know too that MINUSTAH troops have been accused of murdering a young boy in Cap-Haitien, Haiti’s second largest city, in [...]

  11. Inexcusable. Newsweek leads the pack with shallow, ill-informed Haiti journalism. Another media is possible. | Mediahacker Says:

    [...] Some of it will finance my own long-delayed trip to northern city of Cap Haitien, where the possible murder of a boy by UN peacekeepers are gone totally uninvestigated by American journalists for over two [...]

  12. Anger Erupts at U.N. in Haiti as Cholera Toll Nears 1,000 | Mediahacker Says:

    [...] and boiled over into protests several times since the body of teenaged Gerard Jean Gilles was found hanging from a tree inside a Cap-Haitien peacekeeping base in late [...]

  13. Global Voices in English » Haiti: Anti-UN Protests Escalate Over Cholera Epidemic Says:

    [...] claiming that the epidemic was caused by “excrement from Nepalese peacekeepers.” It is no secret that the occupying UN forces, known as MINUSTAH, have a troubled history in Haiti; bloggers have [...]

  14. Haiti: Anti-UN Protests Escalate Over Cholera Epidemic @ Current Affairs Says:

    [...] claiming that the epidemic was caused by “excrement from Nepalese peacekeepers.” It is no secret that the occupying UN forces, known as MINUSTAH, have a troubled history in Haiti; bloggers have [...]

  15. Haiti: Anti-UN Protests Escalate Over Cholera Epidemic :: Elites TV Says:

    [...] claiming that the epidemic was caused by “excrement from Nepalese peacekeepers.” It is no secret that the occupying UN forces, known as MINUSTAH, have a troubled history in Haiti; bloggers have [...]

  16. The UN in Haiti « Jadehawk's Blog Says:

    [...] but instead has been guilty of , among other things, violently suppressing protests, massacres, individual killings, and rape? Would you trust an organization of “peacekeepers” from countries with [...]

  17. Global Voices teny Malagasy » Haiti: Fihetsiketsehana hanoherana ny Firenena Mikambana vokatry ny kôlera Says:

    [...] miaramila misatro-manga avy any Nepal” no nahatonga ny aretina.” Efa tsy tsiambaratelo fa ny andiany mpitandro ny filaminana fantatra amin'ny hoe  MINUSTAH, no malaza amin'ny [...]

  18. Alliance for Global Justice » Blog Archive » Haiti One Year Later: Still Waiting On Aid Says:

    [...] organizations are numerous citations of human rights abuses, including responsibility for the killings of slum dwellers, political activists and even a mourner at the funeral of human rights activist-priest Father Jean Juste. Currently, the [...]